Paint or Stain: What’s Best for Your Project?

Color Store • October 9, 2023

Paint and stain are both widely used for different home improvement projects. But should you give your porch that pop of color or let the wood’s natural beauty shine through? At Color Store, we specialize in Benjamin Moore paint, stain, and primer for interior and exterior surfaces. We’ll discuss the pros and cons of each to help you gain a better idea of what will best suit your project.

Bucket of paint with painting supplies stacked on top of it

When to Choose Paint

Painting is a cost-effective way to give an antique armoire or old bench swing a fresh look. It’s available in a rainbow of colors and is easy to apply with a brush, sprayer, or roller. Some of the most significant advantages of interior and exterior paint include:

  • Opacity: Paint delivers complete coverage, so you need fewer coats.
  • Versatility: You can paint over stains, but not the other way around.
  • Finish: From matte to glossy or metallic, every vision has a paint finish.
  • Refinish process: Repainting later requires scraping and sanding, adding time to your project.

Plus, paint formulas adhere to a wider variety of materials than stain formulas, such as

  • Drywall
  • Wood
  • PVC
  • Vinyl
  • Cement
  • Masonry
  • Metal

Benjamin Moore paint is uniquely engineered for indoor and outdoor environments, from the cabinets in your kitchen to the siding on your house. If you need a surface that’s easy to clean or weather the elements, there’s a formula for every project.

When Selecting Wood Stain Is Better

Permeating and enhancing the surface, the stain highlights natural wood grains. It’s excellent for giving furniture, decks, fencing, and other pieces a warm, timeless finish and is often preferred for its strong weather-resistant properties. Here are some of the reasons stain may be better than paint:

  • Opacity: Stain is transparent or semi-transparent, making it the optimal choice for projects that should look authentically natural.
  • Time: Drying faster than paint stain shortens your timeline to completion.
  • Resistance: Wood stains are less prone to chipping, blistering, and scuffs.
  • Surface protection: Stain polishes and protects wood surfaces, enhancing its integrity.

Crafted for superior performance, Benjamin Moore exterior stain comes in several formulas to suit different projects. It’s designed for application to hard and soft woods and binds directly to the fibers. Here’s a breakdown of some of the most common wood stains and how they differ:

  • Oil-based stains tend to dry slower and penetrate deeper, yielding richer color. 
  • Gel stains are thicker, making it easier to lay down an even coat.
  • Water-based stains dry fast and don’t penetrate as deep, creating a softer finish.
  • Oil-based polyurethane creates a hard, durable coating.

Consult Your Local Benjamin Moore Dealer

Let us help you find the perfect Benjamin Moore stain or paint for your next project. Our expert color consultants know our products inside and out and can help you decide on specific colors, formulas, painting supplies, and more. Giving the best this brand offers, we serve customers in Des Moines, Waukee, Iowa, and Omaha, Nebraska. For more information and project ideas, contact us today.

A selection of popular Benjamin Moore green paint colors in a palette near Des Moines & Waukee, iA a
By Color Store November 26, 2025
Browse the perfect green paint colors from Benjamin Moore. Shop your favorite green paint shades near Des Moines & Waukee, iA and Omaha, NE.
Benjamin Moore Color of the Year 2026 Silhouette AF-655 in a room near Waukee & Des Moines, IA and O
By Color Store October 31, 2025
Discover 2026 Benjamin Moore Color of the Year, Silhouette AF-655! Learn how to incorporate the Benjamin Moore Color Trends 2026 Palette near Des Moines & Omaha.
Benjamin Moore Woodluxe® Exterior Stain + Sealer on a deck near Waukee & Des Moines, IA and Omaha, N
By Color Store September 17, 2025
Refresh your deck with a stain and sealer! Choose Benjamin Moore Woodluxe® Exterior Stain + Sealer near Waukee & Des Moines, IA and Omaha, NE.